I read this book shortly after it came out, probably around 1975. I remember that it was long and jumped from point to point annoyingly, but was still readable, and that it contrasted the reputation for high intellect of Robert McNamara, McGeorge Bundy, Maxwell Taylor, and other officials with their actual floundering and self-delusion.
--- The focus, as I recall, was the harm they brought on the US, not the 2,000,000 Indochinese deaths we caused for nothing. (Old US bombs are still killing -- 62,000 since war's end.)
--- I recall the War itself and the kill-tallies reported on the nightly news. Soldiers were pressed to kill as many "Gooks" (Vietnamese) as they could every day. Every Gook killed was assumed to be VC (Communist) because they killed him. Farmers were mowed down from helicopters; they would always run, proving they were VC. Villages were burned to the ground by our forces. By wiping out the whole population of certain areas, we were sure to get the VC hiding among them.
--- The pretext for the War was the faked Gulf of Tonkin incident.
--- Much more has since been written. See my comment to audiobook entry for Nick Turse, KILL ANYTHING THAT MOVES.
There is a reason he won the Pulitzer. This book is a must read for anyone wishing to understand Vietnam.
I’d suggest its also a great read for our current situation and to understand the role of the press in a free society.
This is one of those misinformational books told to us from the POV that the politicians were in control, not simply the lackeys fulfilling their paymasters' directives. It is telling that John McCain writes the foreward, given that McCain only gained admittance to the Naval Academy because of his father and grandfather [both admirals] and that McCain bombed his own aircraft carrier, crashed a bunch of planes while PUI, and lasted but a few hours in combat before being shot down and captured. Also, his daddy was LBJ's coverup specialist when Israel attacked the USS Liberty and killed many US Navy seamen. [When reading this keep in mind: declassified memos from the State Department in the late 1990s verified that JFK ordered the withdrawl of all US military advisors from Vietnam to begin in late November of 1963, advisors originally dispatched there by President Eisenhower, and that it was LBJ who dramatically incrteased the military there and throughout Southeast Asia. When reading this, be sure to also read Donald Gibson's book, Battling Wall Street: the Kennedy presidency.]
Psychological and personal profiles of the men involved in developing/ maintaining the policies that led to our involvement in Vietnam.
November 2010 :
A fascinating documentation of the early Kennedy/Johnson years and the players involved in the deepening American involvement in Vietnam up until 1968.
Arguably the best book written about the Vietnam war.
There are no ages for this title yet.
There are no summaries for this title yet.
There are no notices for this title yet.
There are no quotes for this title yet.