The Quiet Americans

The Quiet Americans

Four CIA Spies at the Dawn of the Cold War -- A Tragedy in Three Acts

Book - 2020
Average Rating:
Rate this:
"At the end of World War II, the United States dominated the world militarily, economically, and in moral standing - seen as the victor over tyranny and a champion of freedom. But it was clear - to some - that the Soviet Union was already executing a plan to expand and foment revolution around the world. The American government's strategy in response relied on the secret efforts of a newly-formed CIA. THE QUIET AMERICANS chronicles the exploits of four spies - Michael Burke, a charming former football star fallen on hard times, Frank Wisner, the scion of a wealthy Southern family, Peter Sichel, a sophisticated German Jew who escaped the Nazis, and Edward Lansdale, a brilliant ad executive. The four ran covert operations across the globe, trying to outwit the ruthless KGB in Berlin, parachuting commandos into Eastern Europe, plotting coups, and directing wars against Communist insurgents in Asia. But time and again their efforts went awry, thwarted by a combination of stupidity and ideological rigidity at the highest levels of the government - and more profoundly, the decision to abandon American ideals. By the mid-1950s, the Soviet Union had a stranglehold on Eastern Europe, the U.S. had begun its disastrous intervention in Vietnam, and America, the beacon of democracy, was overthrowing democratically-elected governments and earning the hatred of much of the world. All of this culminated in an act of betrayal and cowardice that would lock the Cold War into place for decades to come. Anderson brings to the telling of this story all the narrative brio, deep research, skeptical eye, and lively prose that made LAWRENCE IN ARABIA a major international bestseller. The intertwined lives of these men began in a common purpose of defending freedom, but the ravages of the Cold War led them to different fates. Two would quit the CIA in despair, stricken by the moral compromises they had to make; one became the archetype of the duplicitous and destructive American spy; and one would be so heartbroken he would take his own life. THE QUIET AMERICANS is the story of these four men. It is also the story of how the United States, at the very pinnacle of its power, managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory".-- Provided by publisher.
Publisher: New York :, Doubleday,, [2020]
Edition: First edition
ISBN: 9780385540452
Branch Call Number: 327.1273 Anderson 2020
Characteristics: x, 560 pages : illustrations ; 25 cm


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Jan 05, 2021

The primary villains of this story are J. Edgar Hoover and Dwight Eisenhower. Anderson thoroughly explains why Eisenhower, in his abandonment of Hungary during the 1956 uprising, sealed the fate of the US to be, in a sense, the permanent "opposition party" to the Soviets, one which thrived more on protest than meaningful action. While we like to think about the Cold War era as a time in which the lines between good and evil were clear, in truth it was during this period that the United States developed a reputation, domestically and abroad, that couldn't possibly mean what it said.

The essential problem was that, despite the numerous adventures the US pursued all over the globe, the issue was always the European countries trapped behind the Iron Curtain. Well-chosen anecdotes from the perspectives of both Frank Wisner and Peter Sichel about Romania and Germany, respectively, drive home the point that Stalin's USSR was absolutely monstrous, and the veterans of World War II in Europe who worked at the nascent CIA were genuinely driven to take down an enemy they (rightfully) perceived as evil.

But a decade of fighting in Europe -- plus many more years of purging in the USSR -- made it, in the end, impossible for the US to establish a foothold in these countries during the 40s and 50s, much less release the stranglehold on those governments. And when the US was able to engage any actors, they were frequently left with the worst of the worst, many of who had Nazi bona-fides. While many may feel those relationships themselves tainted the United States, Anderson points out that we had few options: after repeated sweeps by the Soviets and the Nazis, the vast majority of the "good guys" in many of these countries had been killed. If we were going to work with anyone, we had few choices.

To the CIA's credit, they did try to work with resistance movements in these countries. Unfortunately, the CIA's intelligence about these movements were spotty at best, and the missions they proposed based on that intelligence immediately raised the eyebrows of the people who were assigned to oversee them, personified here by Michael Burke. It took a few years for the leadership of the CIA to finally catch on to the fact that they were, in many cases, being baited by the governments of those countries, most notoriously in Poland. While they were being thwarted by shocking intelligence leaks -- particularly by MI6 agent Kim Philby -- one gets the sense that closing those leaks wouldn't have changed the facts on the ground.

Korea in 1950 caught Washington by surprise, and alerted them to the fact that communism could spread outside of the European theater. (It should be noted here that while the Truman administration was caught off-guard, the CIA had, in fact, alerted them to the likelihood of action by the North Koreans.) This was, indeed, part of the justification for bringing the anti-Communist fight to other parts of the world, particularly Guatemala, Iran, and Vietnam. Pity there wasn't much of a Communist movement in those places before that. But the real reason is clear: the US couldn't win in Europe, but we could win elsewhere.

We couldn't win until we could -- but we chose not to. Although Hungary gave us the resistance movement we had desperately sought in the 40s, by 1956 we were convinced that anything that looked like victory against the Communists was a convoluted trick. (Including genuine overtures by the Politburo and Kruschev after Stalin's death.) Cold feet might be forgiven but for our intentional machinations at the UN designed to stall any meaningful action. This is in part be explained by the paranoia Hoover sowed into American culture, but was also a result of the defense policy, which favored nuclear weapons and covert action, but not traditional combat. Unfortunately, this was not aligned with our statements, which Hungarians interpreted as a promise for aid.

A great story, but no easy solutions. Highly recommended.


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at OPL

To Top